Difference between revisions of "Policy setup and structure"

From PostgreSQL_wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 1: Line 1:
 
The current version of the Webhuis CFEngine policies are an evolution of [[Dynamic_CFEngine3|Dynamic CFEngine]].
 
The current version of the Webhuis CFEngine policies are an evolution of [[Dynamic_CFEngine3|Dynamic CFEngine]].
== Criticism of [[Dynamic_CFEngine3|Dynamic CFEngine]] ==
+
== Disadvantages of [[Dynamic_CFEngine3|Dynamic CFEngine]] ==
 
Convergence is one of the fundamental principles of CFEngine the dynamic setup relies on too heavily, because policies are being used to identify dependent and subsequent policies. Policies are being derived from the concept of the 'role' a system has, components are defined in the role and convergently become available to the system. A role has one or more components that may depend on the platform or the flavor of the system. Convergence towards the Desired State is meant for configuring a system, not for the composition of the policy set.<br />
 
Convergence is one of the fundamental principles of CFEngine the dynamic setup relies on too heavily, because policies are being used to identify dependent and subsequent policies. Policies are being derived from the concept of the 'role' a system has, components are defined in the role and convergently become available to the system. A role has one or more components that may depend on the platform or the flavor of the system. Convergence towards the Desired State is meant for configuring a system, not for the composition of the policy set.<br />
 
* This may lead to a temporarily inconsistent policy set
 
* This may lead to a temporarily inconsistent policy set

Revision as of 19:31, 8 July 2025

The current version of the Webhuis CFEngine policies are an evolution of Dynamic CFEngine.

Disadvantages of Dynamic CFEngine

Convergence is one of the fundamental principles of CFEngine the dynamic setup relies on too heavily, because policies are being used to identify dependent and subsequent policies. Policies are being derived from the concept of the 'role' a system has, components are defined in the role and convergently become available to the system. A role has one or more components that may depend on the platform or the flavor of the system. Convergence towards the Desired State is meant for configuring a system, not for the composition of the policy set.

  • This may lead to a temporarily inconsistent policy set
  • Developers tend to reject this setup, they want to have the policy set available right from the beginning
  • The role concept as it was, was far from perfect, because of the redundancy in the different roles.

More on Roles

The role defines the system in every aspect.

  • The hardware it has available
  • The software it autonomously installs, configures and runs

Many roles look similar when it comes to many configuration aspects, but there always are those little differences. Those differences prevent the definition of a generic policy and provide redundancy in policies at best. Large parts of the role redundantly define the promises.

Enter the Role Profile concept.

Role Profile

The concept of 'role' and components had to be refined in order to meet the requirement of generic policies while avoiding redundancy.


Return to: CFEngine